# Claim table — Garnet Harper transplant-denial video

| Claim / issue | Source status | PBC label |
|---|---|---|
| Garnet Harper was denied kidney-transplant assessment/listing because he was unvaccinated for COVID-19. | Claimed in the X video transcript and in the related Juno News video description. | Strong video/media claim; primary hospital/transplant records still wanted. |
| His brothers were willing living donors. | Claimed in X video transcript and Juno description. | Claim preserved; family/hospital documentation still wanted. |
| LHSC or Ontario transplant policy later changed the kidney requirement from a COVID-vaccine requirement to a recommendation. | Claimed in Juno description. | Important policy-change claim; needs official LHSC/Ontario Health source. |
| The case belongs in the Allison Inquiry file. | Allison Inquiry is collecting testimony/claims from Canadians reporting COVID-19 vaccine injury and COVID-era policy harms; the video is a COVID-era medical-policy claim. | Relevant PBC Allison Inquiry / records-wanted post, not an official Allison finding. |
| “Policy over patient” / “medical tyranny.” | Video commentary language. | Opinion/framing; PBC preserves it as the video’s frame but separates it from documented facts. |